The fragile pause in Israel’s conflict with Hamas in Gaza has allowed the release of 58 hostages, but the ongoing battle between the two sides remains a concern. The enduring pause has allowed for the return of more hostages and aid entry into Gaza. With President Joe Biden in Washington, the fighting in Gaza could potentially resurface again, making it more intractable and costly. The situation highlights the brutal toll of the ongoing conflict in the Middle East.
The Israeli Cabinet and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have discussed extending extra days of pauses in Israeli strikes in exchange for the freeing of each group of 10 hostages in Gaza. Hamas is pushing for an extension of the deal, with the US and Qatar seeking to use the momentum of the pause to create a foundation for a more permanent end to the fighting. In the short term, Israel and Hamas have strong reasons to continue the truce, with Netanyahu potentially receiving political relief as more hostages return home. The US is seeking the return of Americans held or unaccounted for after the Hamas raids, and Biden has a strong imperative to delay or prevent more civilian carnage in Gaza.
A suspect, Jason J. Eaton, was arrested in the shooting of three Palestinian college students in Vermont. The incident occurred near the scene of the attack, which follows an increase in antisemitism that has made American Jews feel less safe despite the ongoing conflict between Gaza and Israel. The charges against Eaton remain unclear.
What caused the Gaza ceasefire to break down in the future?
The Israeli government is grappling with a moral dilemma as the fate of the remaining hostages, including a large group of young males and some members of the Israeli security forces, remains uncertain. The current situation allows Hamas to set the tempo of the conflict by using hostages as leverage to shape Israeli responses and military activity. The pause complicates Israel’s drive to wipe out the Islamist movement, and the broader goals of the Israeli military increasingly pose the fate of the remaining hostages.
The lopsided nature of the exchanges, which involve three Palestinians released from Israeli prisons in exchange for each hostage, may become politically unsustainable for Netanyahu’s government, whose reeling government relies on a coalition of hawkish far-right parties. As the number of its hostages dwindles, Hamas may lose the incentive to free large groups as it seeks to retain leverage. The US perspective is uncertain about how much pressure Biden will impose on the Israelis to continue the pause as long as possible. Hamas may hold onto some American hostages to keep the US focused on this and pressure Israel. A return to battle might weaken Israel’s already shaky international backing.
President Biden faces a balancing act in Gaza, as he believes any country, including Israel, has a right and responsibility to defend itself against such an enemy. Sullivan, Biden’s national security adviser, emphasized the importance of protecting civilians and distinguishing terrorists from civilians.
The release of hostages and over 100 trucks of humanitarian aid have provided a rare moment of hope and relief in the conflict. 4-year-old Abigail Edan, the youngest American held, was released on Sunday, marking the first US citizen freed since the truce began. Biden spoke with the family of the girl, whose parents were both murdered on October 7, and expressed her trauma. Biden’s address was a welcome break in a crisis that has caused him considerable political damage. However, with low approval ratings and political attacks from all sides, as he seeks reelection, the president faces a difficult road ahead, especially if the fighting resumes in Gaza.
Biden has come under fire for not advocating for an end to the Israeli-Palestinian issue, which has exposed divisions within his electoral coalition. Progressive, younger voters—crucial for Biden’s reelection in the next year—have criticized Israel for its handling of the terror incident.
Anger is also rising among Arab Americans, who are crucial to Democrats’ aspirations in Michigan. In the meantime, Republican contender for president, Chris Christie, voiced worry that Biden is taking a strong stance in favor of Netanyahu, saying that he ought to back Israel’s attempts to safeguard the security of its nine million residents and preserve its territorial integrity. Democratic and Republican parties have criticized the president’s position on the war.
Israel might have to wait until next year for a US aid package.
Congress is being called upon to pass $14.3 billion in emergency aid for Israel. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer plans to bring a national security package that includes funding for Israel and Ukraine to the floor. However, this measure may face challenges in the GOP-controlled House. House Republicans have passed their bar, including cuts to IRS funding that Democrats find unacceptable. Pro-Trump Republicans oppose combining the bar with a $60 billion aid package for Ukraine. The narrow House GOP majority, controlled by hardliners, means that Republicans may only support an action if it includes Democratic concessions on the southern border.
House Intelligence Chairman Mike Turner expressed uncertainty about the passage of a measure to protect Palestinian civilians in Israel, citing the White House policy on the southern border as the main obstacle. Sen. Chris Murphy expressed openness to conditioning Israeli aid on the protection of Palestinian civilians, stating that assistance to allies is based on compliance with US and international law. The political strategizing in Israel, the United States, and beyond has not considered the region’s future post-war. The Biden administration supports a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In contrast, Israeli President Isaac Herzog endorses the idea of an international coalition to monitor Gaza after Hamas’s elimination. However, the critical question is how long the war will be paused and whether hostages will continue to be sent to freedom and safety.
